Open Letter To Michelle Dewberry and the people of Chiconomise

August 13th, 2009

Dear Michelle,

Whilst aimlessly surfing the web the other day, I came across your new venture, chiconomise.  I have to confess I would have expected more from someone who made it through the gruelling self flagulation which is the apprentice.  The nation expected great things from you, Michelle, is chiconomise your magnum opus?

On the positive side it’s great to see that you have not been idle, and I am a great fan of being entrepreneurial (agency is the engine of mental development as my old lecturer used to say).  But why, oh why did you choose to launch a deals site?   I am no great expert on running sites like these but I reckon that it must be pretty hard to make a living from affiliate schemes and advertising alone.  No doubt it requires being really, really, really good at search engine optimisation and by the looks of things, you are not a scolar of the Google arts.

Having said that I think you have got some good content on the site and it’s great to see that you are making use of social media such as blogging and Twitter.  For starters, here are some suggestions for what I’d do differently:

  • Landing page for each brand.  Currently most of your offers link straight to the destination website.  Check out what My Voucher codes do, they have a page where all the offers from a particular brand are located.  Bare in mind that in other ways My voucher codes are really annoying, like trying to flog me stupidly expensive advertising
  • Improve your <title>s and meta data.  Get the basics right, it can only increase your traffic
  • Don’t use images as blog post titles.  It may look cool, but Google can’t read them.  And incidentally how am I supposed to subscribe to your blog, there does not appear to be an RSS feed.
  • Start a forum.  C’mon, you site is crying out for this
I could go on, but I think that is food for thought.  You have a lot of work to do.

Bye for now,

Trevor

If you found this post useful, why not buy me a coffee!

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati

Online Credit Card Fraud – Know the Risks

July 22nd, 2009

Card payments, either directly or via eWallet services like PayPal, make up the vast majority of payments for goods online.  Consumers are well protected against fraud with the, however, merchants do not enjoy the same blanket level of protection and need to be careful when accepting online payments.

Online payments funded by a card can be subject to charge backs, where the card holder disputes the transaction up to 6 months after the sale.  Charge backs can either be because the card holder disputes that they made the transaction (i.e. it was a fraudulent transaction), or because they believe that the item they received was not as described.

Who Carries the Risk?

It is easy to assume that funds arriving in an account are cleared and legitimate payments.  However, for any online payments where the 3D secure test is not passed (see below), the merchant carries the ultimate risk of a fraud as the transaction is ‘card holder not present’.  To understand the risks associated with any transaction, merchants should understand the available security checks and other factors which can be used to filter out the good from the bad.

Card Security Checks

In my experience payment gateways make little effort to educate their customers as to the best security settings for their business and leave the merchant to create their own security settings.  However, it pays to spend some time working out the best settings for your business.  For example, if your products are all low value, you may wish to have a low security threshold as fraud is unlikely or a risk you are willing to take.  Conversely, if your products are desirable, high ticket items, then fraud settings should be high.

3D Secure

3D secure, also know as Verified by Visa or Mastercard SecureCode creates a virtual “card present” environment during internet transactions by asking the buyer to enter a password. 3D secure is only available for Visa and Mastercard transactions and as yet there are no similar initiatives for American Express, JCB or Diner’s Club.

The major benefit of this system is that a transaction that has been fully 3D Secure validated, cannot be charged-back to the merchant if subsequently found to be fraudulent. The merchant is protected by the card issuer against such charge backs because the bank themselves assume the liability.  However, charge backs are still possible as a 3D secure validated transaction will not protect in the event of the customer denying receipt of goods.

3D secure is not universally popular with some merchants complaining of reduced conversions.  Some consumers also find the extra step in the checkout process annoying.

AVS (Address Verification Service)

AVS checks the numeric values in a card holder’s address (i.e. flat or house number and numbers in the post code) given at checkout against the billing address on file for the card.  Checking that the buyer knows the right billing address is an important extra check, but by no means fool proof.  For example, a card owner can enter their address incorrectly, or a fraudster can have access to the card holder’s address.   The AVS result can be either match, partial match or mismatch.

CV2 (a.k.a CVV and CVVC)

These are the three numbers which are on the back of the card for Visa and Mastercard, or four on the front (American Express).  Their purpose is to provide some confidence that the buyer has the card in their possession as the numbers are not stored on the magnetic strip.  The system is by no means foolproof as the there are scripts available on the internet for generating the codes.

Fraud Screening

With experience humans can get a feeling for whether or not a transaction poses a risk.  However as transaction volumes grow, it is not possible to check each purchase individually.  Fraud screening services such as Third Man (www.the3rdman.co.uk) automate the analysis of each transaction by looking at various elements including name, card numbers, frequency of use, delivery address, value and IP address and produce a risk score for the transaction.  Fraud services are integrated into many payment gateways such as SagePay.

As well as using automated services, be aware of the following warning factors:

  • Use of free email addresses with names unrelated to the name given
  • Incomplete contact details
  • Orders which are unusually large or have a strange combination of items
  • Billing and delivery addresses different.  Be especially wary if the delivery address is a hotel or guest house
  • Be wary of customers who ask insist on obtaining tracking number for deliveries, they could be trying to intercept the delivery.

A full list can be found here:

http://www.the3rdman.co.uk/fraud-screening-advice.php

Security of common Payment Gateways

PayPal

PayPal’s website payments standard product only provides seller protection for purchases which go to verified addresses.  All purchases which are made using the Website Payments Pro service are ineligible for seller protection.  AVS is available through PayPal but 3D secure is not supported and there is no additional fraud screening.

Google Checkout

Google provides merchants with details of whether a transaction has passed CV2 and AVS tests.  It does not support 3D secure, but does provide its own chargeback protection for eligible transactions.

SagePay

SagePay allows merchants to set their own security rules for AVS, CV2 and 3D secure.  It also provides a risk score for each transaction in conjunction with Third Man.

If you found this post useful, why not buy me a coffee!

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati

Interview with Matt Rogers from Aroxo

July 20th, 2009

If you have met Matt Rogers, you will know that he is a driven and dedicated individual with big ambitions for his start-up, Aroxo.  He is going to need all his determination to take on the big boys, amazon and eBay in the marketplace business.  I was skeptical to begin with, but having met him, I think he might just do it.  Over to you Matt.

Please tell us about Aroxo – how did you get the idea

Aroxo is a totally new and unique marketplace that helps buyers and sellers for products and services negotiate with each other. Aroxo’s model is buyer-driven.

The buyer creates what we call a Want-it Note, this tells Aroxo sellers what they want and they price they want to pay. They then receive offers from sellers and can either buy straight away, or negotiate with the seller.

For sellers we’re an entirely new channel to market enabling them to sell stock in volume, whilst allowing differential pricing to be achieved and managed on mass. We’re finding that a lot of our negotiations are affectively price matches, enabling a seller who would otherwise have lost a sale to a competitor to ship some stock and take a margin.

The potential market for the platform is huge. We are currently deliberately restricting it to consumer electronics whilst we build scale and users. Aroxo will be rolled out to wider markets once we have built traction and brand recognition.

Taking on eBay and amazon is something between difficult and impossible – discuss!

eBay and amazon are locked in a battle at the moment. eBay is fighting more and more for the fixed price business, and amazon is trying to grow its business by bringing more sellers onto their platform through their Marketplace.

In the meantime they are ignoring their users.

Both amazon and eBay are riddled with knock-off grey products from overseas. Their search basically doesn’t work (green ipod on eBay returns no Ipods, let alone anything green, and MP3 Players on amazon returns no iPods and a large proportion of Chinese knock-offs).

These are both amazing businesses, but amazon’s product catalogue is a mess and eBay’s user experience is very poor.

This is fertile ground for start-ups who can really focus on solving the needs of the customer:

  1. Product discovery
  2. Amazing prices
  3. Easy to use
  4. Ease of integration

We’re laser-like focused on these to deliver value to buyers and sellers by focussing on nothing but these.

I see integration as the key here, how do merchants upload their inventory to Aroxo

We’ve done a lot of work in this space to make it really easy for merchants to sell through us.

We do three things to make the merchant’s life easier. Firstly they can import their entire stock feed using our live feed import. We process everything in real-time and the entire catalogue is usually live within a few minutes of upload. We also support a wide range of different feed formats.

Secondly, we handle a lot of work-flow for them. We help them track payments, print address labels (if needed!), manage pre-sales and post-sale customer enquiries, feedback and manage their account. We do this using an easy-to-use “task list” that brings everything together in a clear list. Do the job on the top, and then come straight back to the list.

Finally, we’re very flexible with the payment systems which the seller can support. Any seller who accepts either Sagepay/Protx, PayPal, Google Checkout and telephone orders and take payments through Aroxo. We’re adding Worldpay support in soon too. The money goes direct into the seller’s account, and so can be passed through their own preferred fraud prevention tools.

An entirely new seller can be up and selling on Aroxo within 30 mins.

How has the service been doing so far?

Great! Since we’ve launched we’ve already won a number of awards for our technology, including:

  • Winner: Techcrunch Pitch! 2009 sponsored by UKTI
  • Winner: UK’s Hottest Start-up 2009, London Business School, Technology Summit
  • Nominee: Techcrunch Europas. Best start-up 2009
  • Finalist: The Next Web, Europe’s Most Promising Start-Up

At Aroxo we’re building out our seller base. We’ve already got tens of millions of pounds worth of stock on the site and handling plenty of sales, but we’re always on the look-out for more and more sellers.

If you drop us an email to seller@aroxo.co.uk not only can we help you get integrated, but we can throw in enough Aroxo credit for free to last you for a few months of selling on Aroxo.

Plans for the future?

We’ve got a lot of new features – for buyers and sellers – in the pipeline. The main areas we’re focused on are detailed above. The next major release you’ll see will be around making Aroxo’s product discovering stand out from the crowd, really help buyers find the right product for them.

If you found this post useful, why not buy me a coffee!

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati

Money saving ideas for Entrepreneurs (or anyone for that matter)

July 20th, 2009

Let me let you into a secret, I’m a bit cheap.  Superman had Kryptonite, I have freebies.  In these times of recession, I thought I would share a few of my money saving ideas.  These are specific to business, but are applicable to just about anyone.

Keep Rent Cheap

My office is in the Truman Brewery, Brick Lane, East London.  My unit is cheap as it does not have any windows.  Units with windows cost twice as much and are baking in summer.

Use Voip Phone Systems

I run my business using voipfone, an internet based phone system.  Each number costs me £1 per month as opposed to £10 with BT.

Outsource work to India

I have save £1000 by outsourcing development work and product listing creation to the Far east.  Use sites like eLance to find good, cheap workers.

Cash Back Credit Cards

My credit card pays me 1% cashback on everything I spend.  This year I stand to get several thousand pounds for doing exactly nothing.

Google Apps

I use Google Apps to run my company intra net and email for free.

If you found this post useful, why not buy me a coffee!

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati

Interview with Bastien Duclaux, CEO, Twenga

July 11th, 2009

I am a big fan of Twenga.  I think it is great from a retailers POV as it is free, and great for customers as it has a huge range of products.  i managed to get a interview with the founder, Bastien Duclaux, where he gives some insights into Twenga and the furture of shopping comparison

Could you give us some background on Twenga?

Twenga is a shopping search engine, price comparison site and shopping guide. The company was founded in 2006 by Bastien Duclaux and Cédric Anès, to fill an unsatisfied need for an open shopping search engine.

Before us, first-generation shopping search engines were “walled-garden” price comparison sites: Firstly, they were focused on price comparison, rather than on product search to match consumer needs. Secondly, they were only displaying the offers of those retailers with whom they have a commercial relationship (hence the term ‘walled garden’).

There was a need to break these limitations. We wanted to offer online shoppers the democracy of free and open choices, to give them access to all retailers, not just a few. This is why we developed a technology that gathers shopping data from the entire web and displays it in one searchable interface. One main element of our technology is a dedicated and proprietary “crawl engine” which automatically scans and analyzes the retail offerings of 200 million multilingual Web pages every day.

Why should consumers use Twenga instead of Shopping.com or Google product search?

Looking at the category of price comparison sites, rather than at a specific competitor, we can say that current leaders have pioneered the first generation of price comparison sites. As we mentioned earlier, these competitors operate in a “walled-garden” mode in that they display only the offers of the retailers with whom they have a commercial relationship.

For consumers, the main benefit of using Twenga is to gain access to a much bigger, more diverse, and more representative set of retailers, which in turn brings more objective and better search results. ‘More products from more online shops’ means for consumers the assurance to find what they want at the best price on the market.

We use our technology to automatically index all of the retailers and we are adding hundreds of new retailers every day. We are comprehensive and democratic. On average, we display three to ten times more offers than our competitors in a similar shopping category. Our ultimate goal is to be exhaustive and to become the primary destination for online shopping.

Among our differentiating services, those that are most popular among our users are price history and price alerts. Consumers can check the price trend of a product and create an alert to receive a mail when the price of that particular product drops.

We also offer a free mobile iPhone price comparison application. We are one of very few sites that allow international price comparisons across countries. And we have many more innovative services in store.

Could you explain the promotional options for merchants on Twenga?

We offer the retailers a complete range of promotional options. We offer standard advertising placements such as banner ads or sponsored links, as well as custom advertising packages for specific campaigns.

Our most innovative marketing offer (and our main source of revenue) is performance-based marketing. Retailers who want to boost the visibility of their brand and products on our sites can join our affiliation programme to get additional visibility in dedicated placements on our sites. In addition to being listed among natural search results, their offers are then displayed in dedicated premium placements which are clearly high-lighted and contextualized to best match user searches – thereby driving significantly more traffic and sales.

The retailer’s participation in our affiliate program is completely risk-free because our commission is based solely on completed sales. Retailers increase their visibility and pay Twenga only if it generates revenues. Our 100% performance related model means that every marketing penny spent with us is actually linked to a completed sale!

In the current economic climate, online retailers love Twenga’s performance-based model because it gives them full control on the return of their online marketing investments.

What do you think that the future holds for Twenga and the shopping comparison?  Do you think that that other services will move to a CPA based model?

We position ourselves as a shopping search engine, not only as a price comparison site. Online consumers, especially these days, are focused on price. Hence, price comparison is indispensable, but it is not a sufficient condition to serve online shoppers well. We must also show consumers the right product at the right time. Our ambition is to give to online consumers access to the full richness and diversity of the shopping Web, without the complexity of having to tread through thousands of different sites and irrelevant offers.

We are of course 100% convinced that performance-based marketing is the way of the future. We have no doubt that our competitors want to follow suit. However, it is difficult for them to drop their CPC model, simply because it is a “comfortable”, if not easy model. Performance-based marketing has to be earned by performance; it’s much harder to make money in this model. Twenga was founded on the basis of the CPA model, thus we’re entirely geared to it. We believe that it is much harder for a company who was geared to function in a CPC model to switch to CPA because CPA involves the full complexity of the visit-to-sales conversion process.

Thanks to the pioneering work of companies such as amazon, performance-based marketing models are now well-understood. Their logic is compelling. The tracking technology necessary to make them work well is mature. This is the right time to shift gear and drop the outdated CPC model from the eCommerce space. And that’s what we’re doing. In the future, we anticipate that performance-based marketing will gain ground in multi-channel distribution.

If you found this post useful, why not buy me a coffee!

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati

Why Brands should sell on eBay and Amazon

July 11th, 2009

I recently had a bit of a run in with one of my suppliers, sleepytot.  They have decided to stop supplying companies who sell their products on eBay and amazon or those that sell below the RRP.  I’m not sure if it is strictly speaking legal to constrain the channels which retailers use, or their prices, but anyway, lets look at the two sides of this arguement. I will try, and almost definitely fail to give a balanced view.

The reasons normally given for not wanting items sold on eBay/amazon are they it devalues the brand, mainly for two reasons

  • eBay is seen as disreputable in some way.  I suppose as eBay sells such a wide range of items including new, old and yes, fakes, it is not seen as the kind of neighbourhood people want their brand hanging out in
  • Prices.  Prices on eBay are rarely the RRP and their don’t want their offline and off-marketplace customers to be undercut.
Here are my reasons why brands should allow their products to be sold on eBay and amazon
  • They are going to be sold their anyway.  There is no way they can stop the sale of second hand items
  • International exposure.  A significant propotion of marketplace activity is international
  • Search exposure.  For any given product search, eBay and amazon items will probably rank quite highly
  • Additional sales opportunities.  The more a product can get in front of customers, the more chances there are for a sale.
As a final observation, in my experience it is the smaller (and unfortunately smaller minded) manufacturers who have kittens about their products going on marketplaces.  The larger brands are much more savvy.
Some hard figures for you.  In the past year I have sold 56 sleepytots, 30 of which were on eBay, 4 on amazon and 22 on hellobabydirect.co.uk.  I think that this shows that any merchant that dismisses eBay and amazon is missing out on sales.

If you found this post useful, why not buy me a coffee!

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati

10 Lessons for life from Will Wynne of Arena Flowers

June 16th, 2009

I am a great fan of The Fog of War,  a documentary where Robert McNamara (JFK’s Defence Secretary) gives 11 lessons from his long life.  I thought I would like to try and emulate this documentary in my own small way with a series of posts where people give their lessons for life.  My first subject is Will Wynne from Arena Flowers.  Will is the only person I know who has a tribute twitter account as well as a real one.  Take it away Will:

When Trevor asked me to write up a guest post I figured that I’d try to do something a little different.  So I decided to write a list not of what we consider the most important parts of founding a business, but a list of the ten things that caught us by surprise or that we never really expected.  You may think some of these are obvious, but for us they weren’t.  This topic also means I avoid giving away all our trade secrets and competitive advantages.

NB we are not a hugely venture capital funded business, more of a bootstrapped start up with limited resources, so some of our issues may not be relevant for a mega VC funded start up…

So, without further ado, here we go:

    1. Everything that can go wrong probably will at some point

Bad things happen.  Bright eyed start ups never expect them as that stuff happens to “other people”.  If you’re lucky that might be the case, but in reality, there’s a reason that big businesses have disaster recovery plans; because they’re needed.  Some examples, none of them our fault (honest!):

  • Exploding three phase electricity blowing all power at Flowers HQ for 3 days (despite us rewiring the whole building before moving in);
  • A 6 day internet outage in Park Royal, the biggest business park in Europe (our DSL supplier invoked “Act of God” clauses to get out their responsibilities – it was actually a man with a digger cutting 6000 the cables);
  • Death.  It’s not a nice topic and no one likes to talk about it, but people do die.  We never gave a moment’s thought to the possibility that if someone’s relative/partner/friend died, they would disappear at very short notice for weeks leaving our already very lean team totally overstretched;

There are many more examples of totally unpredictable disruptions I could give, but I’ll spare you.  The point is the unthinkable does happen and you need to at least have thought about it, even if you don’t enjoy doing so.  We find “manage the downside and the upside will take care of itself” a useful maxim to keep our minds focused on this point.

    2. Legals

Everyone knows this stuff crops up and I nodded absentmindedly when told “take care of the legals” as I’d said this myself before in my days working in venture capital.  Let’s be honest, legals are really boring. But get them wrong and you’ll pay the price.  At some point most business will have a disagreement with one or all of a supplier, an investor, a competitor, an employee, the government, a plagiarist or just a random nutter (we picked up a weird stalker/troll just recently).

The “gentleman’s agreement” – ie a deal that isn’t properly written down and documented is a prime culprit here, as it leaves room for different interpretations through being too unspecific.  At the very least, get things spelled out in a clear and detailed email that can be referred back to reliably.  NB legals don’t necessarily require lawyers. Legals just need doing.

This is also an interesting article from the Harvard Business School on the top ten legal mistakes made by entrepreneurs.

    3. The stress is massive, but not in the way you expect

When I talked about the stress to friends, they would typically look sort sympathetic but would clearly be  thinking “good, it shouldn’t be too easy”.  Our senior team members have all run teams before, but previously it wasn’t, ultimately, our fault if the overall business went wrong.  Now, if it does, it is.  Wasn’t easy in the early days when we had no money in the bank and I would meet one of our driver’s newborn sons and try to smile in a calm way and say “Ah, isn’t he cute!” when actually I was thinking “I hope we don’t screw this up and have to lay off your father”.  Such thoughts don’t make for restful sleep!

My father runs businesses in the Congo and I remember when I explained this feeling of mild panic and terror to him he said “Finally. Someone else in the family knows how it feels.”  He then added, “Don’t worry. Just be calm, logical and do what’s right”.  Sound advice.

Nonetheless, I’m very glad that the mania and mild terror of the early days has at least receded if not disappeared entirely.  I have lost half my hair as a result though. L

    4. Buy this snake oil! NO!

There are a flabbergasting number of people out there selling absolutely nothing for stupid amounts of money.  Such businesses feel very parasitical and probably have a lot of success tapping into the budgets of large businesses that don’t measure the ROI on their spend.  “Only £2k for a ¼ page advert!” in some zero circulation magazine that will never be read.  One lady started shouting at me when I’d politely declined “HOW ARE YOU GOING TO GET ANY CUSTOMERS IF YOU DON’T BUY ADSPACE IN [celebrity home makeover man's] MAGAZINE?!  YOUR BUSINESS IS DOOMED!”. Erm.  Okay.  Thanks for that.

I no longer answer any calls to my mobile from numbers not already in my phone book for fear of a sales call or other random caller.  All calls to the office are screened and our CS team revels in winkling out sly salesmen (salesmen have ways of evading the “So, is this a sales call?” question that would make politicians blush).  Standard answer from CS: “Send [team member] an email”.

Spinvox is also handy, as it turns all voicemails into texts so you don’t waste time calling up to listen to them and you can read them during a meeting without seeming too rude.  Though I didn’t take Spinvox with me when I got an iPhone as the iPhone visual voicemail system is pretty good, though slightly different.

    5. Never ever be dependent on one supplier – they WILL try and abuse that relationship

12th February 2008.  Two days before Valentine’s Day.  Phone call from one of our courier partners (a market leading name). “Hi. There’s a problem with your packaging; it’s leaking.  I’m afraid we’ll have to manually process all your orders.  That will mean a £5.00 surcharge [on top of a similar normal charge per unit].”  Given we were set to send about 4000 orders through that partner that week, this would effectively have cost us £20k.  Nothing had changed in our process for 6 months.  We had asked them to confirm everything was fine weeks before.  They didn’t.  Then their last minute bombshell.

They were simply taking the mickey thinking they could get away with it and help themselves to an extra £20k from our pocket.  Charming.  Sadly for them, we’d recognised this as a risk in December and had just completed an integration with another courier, unbeknownst to the original partner.  We discussed the call, agreed that the original partner was behaving appallingly, and switched ALL our orders to the new partner.  The old partner suddenly began groveling and toad eating for Britain but to no avail; they are now our reserve partner but lost several hundred thousand pounds a year of business by trying to abuse their position.

We could give a number of similar examples.  Simply, if you depend on one partner, you’re over a barrel and they can do what they want.  And they’ll probably try it.  We now ensure we have a back up supplier for every key part of our operation, to spare greedy suppliers such temptations.  PS obviously, this is also important for disaster recovery planning too.

    6. Suppliers can be bigger “investors” than, erm, investors

Pre credit crunch at least, even a new business didn’t find it that hard to get credit from suppliers.  There is a lot of focus put on raising equity from angels, friends, family and so on.  But a lot of the funding requirement can in fact come through credit from suppliers.  One of our suppliers pointed out this out to us once: “How come you owe me more than your investors put together and I own none of the business?”.  Cue awkward silence, shuffling of papers and then saying briskly “Anyway, moving on…!”

It’s not the lowest risk approach ever and not the way to finance a business long term, but it can give extra liquidity that was never expected.

    7. Product Product Product

Business advice talks a lot about SEO, market size, scalability, teamwork, web design, business development, networking, fund raising, financial controls.  All important things.  But all totally useless if you don’t have a decent product.  If you are in a business that gets £1 off people once, then this point is less important.  But if you want repeat business then unless your product is actually any good, it doesn’t matter how good you are at all the other stuff.  It’s only a matter of time til your demise.

We make as sure as we can that, within the constraints of making money, that we provide an outstanding product.  That’s not to say we don’t make mistakes, and, as with all businesses, we can’t please all the people all the time, but, 99% of the time, our product will delight the customer (and recipient) and be better than that of our competitors.  That’s a good foundation on which to build a business.  If you don’t try to deliver the best possible product for your customers then you don’t really deserve to succeed.

    8. Nothing ventured, nothing gained + BONUS: you can rewrite history after the event (if your idea works)

Our conservative instincts tend to make us want to be careful and risk averse.  Mine certainly did.  But a number of times we’ve just said “Ah, let’s just go for it!” and seen where it’s taken us.  For instance, our European expansion could be reframed as a stroke of tactical genius; hindsight is a marvelous thing.  Actually, there was some inspiration, some detailed analysis and strategising but, mostly, there was a large chunk of “Yeah, sounds good. Let’s do it.” luck.  We can now talk wisely about rolling out our operation abroad to cover Europe and develop the brand’s international reach.  At the time it wasn’t nearly so clear cut.  Realising that not everything can be worked out in PowerPoint or in a spreadsheet is a great freedom and lot of fun.  Just don’t expect it to work every time.

    9. Turns out that stuff about team work is actually true

If you’re like me, you’ll probably have always thought that all the “teamwork is great” and “I’m a team player” chat on CVs was interesting but a bit “yeah yeah, whatever, no one cares about that really”.  And in larger companies, in my experience, it was less necessary and sometimes felt somewhat forced.  A fun thing about working at Arena is that there are lots of different types of people: techies, award-winning florists, linguists, operations gurus, flower buying experts, finance bods and so on.  The key is to getting all the different parts to work together and understand the overall business’s priorities because everyone has to muck in to different areas.  If you don’t get on, the business won’t succeed.

One other thing is that you can set the attitudinal weather in a small business around the leadership team’s values.  In our case, we absolutely don’t allow is any petty politicking, childish bickering or any “it’s not my problem, guvnor” rubbish, nor do we blame people for making mistakes – at least not the first time :) .  The aim is to deliver the best service for our customers as efficiently as possible.  Childish spoilt brat behaviour has no place in that process.

    10. It feels good!

“What’s it like to be your own boss?  Do you enjoy it?  Is it all it’s cracked up to be?”  I get asked that a lot. The answer is “Absolutely!”.  At least once you’ve got through the pain and the horror of the start.  Once you’ve broken the back and moved from “start up” to “established [but still young] business” the scales lift from your eyes and you remember what it’s like to be human plus begin to enjoy the freedoms of being your own boss without having a Board sending down instructions and messing you about on HR reviews or telling you what to do and what to think daily.  It’s an incredibly uplifting feeling and I hope never to have to go back.

Seeing teams build and relationships develop and reading emails from elated customers is a great thing when you were part of the team that built it from absolutely nowhere.  One of my favourite things is when people write emails saying “Thanks, Arena!”.  I can still remember the day we sat down and worked out what to call the business; it’s great to hear it taking on a life of its own.

have you got some lessons from life you want to share?  If so please contact me.

If you found this post useful, why not buy me a coffee!

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati

Interview with Paul Fisher from Niggle

June 11th, 2009

In my adventures in online reputation I came across Niggle, a new way for businesses to get feedback from their customers.  As I didn’t give them many column inches before, I caught up with Paul Fisher to get the whole story.

Could you give us some background on Niggle please.  How’s it going?

Niggle’s primary aim is to make it easy and convenient for customers to send feedback to businesses, and to help businesses deal with that feedback in a way that improves their business and bottom line.

The seed of the idea stems from my days as a restaurant owner, when I was totally fascinated by our fluctuating sales patterns and became intensely curious as to what was going on in the minds of my customers.  When I started looking at collecting feedback from customers I found that there are lots of barriers that stop people for communicating directly with businesses, and so Niggle’s job has really been to address those barriers.

Niggle helps businesses to ask for feedback in the right ways.  For example, by using Niggle a business is guaranteeing to it’s customers that their feedback will go to the right person.  We also guarantee that the customer will stay anonymous if they wish while still allowing the business to reply or issue vouchers or rewards.  For businesses with premises, we offer the use of text message feedback, or feedback via Twitter, which is both convenient and instant for the customer.

In the current climate where everything is public, businesses seem to appreciate ways to foster private relationships with customers.  Just one month out of beta testing and we have several hundred independent businesses and a number of small chains using our technology.

Niggle is different from services such as Qype and trusted places in that the feedback is private between the customer and the company. Surely, however this prevents your site from becoming a destination site for consumers looking for information on the best service.  Are you shooting yourself in the foot?

Qype and Trusted places are very much focused on consumers, where we are very much focused on businesses.  If we do our job and enable those businesses to effectively communicate with customers, negative public reviews should be avoided.  In some ways, our website is our last line of defense. First and foremost we aim to pick up customer feedback and complaints by text message or our mobile site while the customer is still on the premises.  It’s only if the customer has managed to get home and get online that they might find our website when searching for a business name. Our hope is that at that point they choose to send direct feedback to the owner rather than post a public review.

The side effect is that our website isn’t a consumer destination, but rather one of many channels in to Niggle.

The British are a reticent bunch and not very good at giving feedback.  Is Niggle going to change that?

As a nation we would rather tell our friends about our experiences than those involved.  It’s all tied up in our famous reserve and embarrassment of uncomfortable social situations, meaning that we have some unique barriers to feedback that are not found elsewhere.  It’s the reason why public review websites have been so readily taken to heart in this country, and the reason we hope Niggle will too!

What are your plans for the future (new functionality etc).

We’re experimenting with lots of interesting new ways to collect feedback. A trial is due to start soon with a national retailer where customers complete a short text message survey in exchange for a discount code sent to their phone. Instant customer rewards break down one of the biggest barriers to feedback – apathy – and can be a great means for businesses to foster customer loyalty.

We are also reviewing the idea of allowing businesses to publish items of feedback, alongside their responses, on our website. This could help businesses avoid repeat questions and also showcase their customer service skills, however we will tread carefully to ensure that we are not perceived as just another review website by customers. Watch this space :)

If you found this post useful, why not buy me a coffee!

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati

Nudges and Credit Card Processing

June 3rd, 2009

I have recently finished reading Nudge by Cass Sunstein and Richard Thaler.  The book suggest strategies for enabling humans to make decisions which are in their interest, such as giving up smoking or saving more, given human shortcomings.  The word humans here is important, as humans are lazy and have inbuilt reasoning biases.  They many not always act in their own interest.

The book talks a lot about decision architecture, that is how to construct a decision making process to enable people to make the more appropiate choice.  How choices are presented will, to a great extent, determine the choices which are made.  For example, in many cases people will simply go for the default choice.  Subsequently defining the default choice becomes very important.

I was reminded of nudges when I was talking today about payment gateways and how awful they are.  These days it is very easy to collect credit card payments on a website via service like Google Checkout and PayPal.  There are however security setting which are very important to fraud prevention which, in my experience, are not properly presented to merchants when they set up their account.  I recently had a big problem when using a provider whoses default security setting was no security.  Guess which setting I had accidentally chosen!

Looking at payment services, it amazes me that they do ot have some sort of wizard to step customers through the process of creating the security setting on their account.  I have setup a Google Checkout and PayPal payments pro account with out any mention of security setting like CV2 and AVS, although their are important security settings.  Sagepay is better, offering merchants an easy way to define their own security settings, but still I had to research the best setting for my business and actively set them up, which is more than a lot of people would do.  I also like the traffic light system which Sagepay uses which I think translates the complicated fraud information into an easy to understand system.

Credit card payment gateways, you don’t have the read Nudge as I have read it for you.  This is what it would recommend:

  • Currently there are too many choices for merchants and more choices is generally just confusing.  Create well constructed default(s) which can be chosen by the merchant.  Allow the merchant to set up their own setting if they wish.
  •  Create an easy to use wizard which allows merchants to choose the security setting most relevant to them based on their appetite for risk.  
  • In this wizard the merchant should be forced to make an active choice of security setting (low, medium, high) as I don’t think a single default setting will be workable.
  • Provide feedback on transactions in an easy to understand way.  For example the some sort of visual traffic light system like that employed by Sagepay
  • Provide regular fraud reporting giving the amount of fraud on the account and comparing it against average for other security settings for comparision.

If you found this post useful, why not buy me a coffee!

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati

In Praise of Toy Shop UK

May 24th, 2009

In my experience very few directories have the potential to drive any kind of traffic and this includes services like Yell and Scoot. (In fact, rather embarrissingly I once bought an entry on Scoot.  The entry produced so little traffic (one hit per month) that I wrote to Michael Grade and got my money back).  Scouring the web for links produces no end of sites that want £10 or so for a listing.  It is rarely worth it.  Most directories are also of very limited use to consumers, giving very limited informations about their entries (i.e. they are for SEO purposes only which is fine, as far as it goes).  They are compiled without TLC.

One notable exception is Toy Shop UK.  This excellent directory is not only free, but generates quite respectable traffic for my site.  The directory allows retailers to add a comprehensive description of their business and categorises by useful categories such as brand of toys, toys sold and location.  In short a rare example of a directory which is both useful to retailers and consumers.  Good work!  Check out the Hello Baby entry.

I caught up with Tim Hawkins from Toy Shop UK, to find out the secret of their success.

Please give us some history behind Toy Shop UK

As ex-independent toy retailers, we wanted to create a site that enabled smaller, independent shop owners to compete on more of a level playing field with the larger national stores.

We came from the basic principle that if you’re not even mentioned, you’ll never get found – so something that helps you to be found for free really is a no-brainer.

Whilst we’re not on any particular crusade to blindly promote independents over larger companies, at the heart of Toy Shop UK we do believe that a characterful and diverse High Street is something that is really special and worth championing. This is even more true online, where independents provide an invaluable service by being able to offer far more expertise and choice in the brands and ranges that they choose to stock.

Although we can’t ‘protect’ independent toy shops against the expansion of national chains, the fact is that we have helped many independent toy shops increase their online sales – and we’re very proud of that.

What do you think makes a good directory and how have you implemented this on your site?

Having submitted to hundreds of directories ourselves for previous businesses, we knew instantly what the main flaws of most directories are.

Slow turnaround times and the inability to speak directly with a real-life administrator were definitely high on our list of gripes. However, the cost of inclusion and the disappointing levels of resulting traffic were easily the two biggest criticisms that can be levelled at virtually every single directory we’ve submitted to.

The price was easy for us to sort out – we simply made it free and decided that we would generate an income from people other than our advertisers.

Generating real traffic for our visitors was a harder task. With the guidance of an online optimisation expert, we’ve worked really hard to create a great looking site with high-quality, original content that is not only found by people searching online for toy-related search terms but is genuinely useful for them too. That probably sounds really obvious, but if you look at most online directories – even the really famous ones like DMOZ they don’t actually provide visitors with any tangible traffic.  Even Yahoo’s Directory which costs $299 to be considered for doesn’t achieve good traffic referrals – and that’s why we wanted to create something different.

Do you think consumers use directories instead of just googling?

Traffic stats for Toy Shop UK show that there is a definite place for directories. This is backed up by high page views and low bounce-rates which reassures us that people are genuinely browsing the site rather than simply finding a result and leaving straightaway.

There’s no doubt that the vast majority of online directories don’t perform any using searching/browsing function and I think that has tarred the reputation of directories in general. That certainly explains why many people just see directories as a necessary evil; something that you have to spend three days submitting to whenever you want to launch a new site.

Many of our listers submit their website simply to get that all important hyperlink – and whilst that is totally understandable, we make a big effort to try and change the perception that all directories are just there as a way to shift Page Rank around the web.

Many of our listers are pretty shocked when they realise that we actually send them a consistent flow of traffic. It might not be huge quantities of traffic but it’s of a good quality, and crucially, it’s targeted. It’s much more likely to have a higher conversion rate than traffic from search engines, simply because a human being that knows the industry inside has already filtered the results and removed all the garbage.

What is your business model?

We decided early on that the site would be free for toy shops to join on whatever level they felt comfortable with. The site has a light sprinkling of Google ads, and there are a few affiliate listers on the site that pay small commissions.

Advertising space will soon be available strictly for manufacturers and suppliers only, in order to maintain complete impartiality for our listers.

New developments are constantly in progress, and as the site becomes even better known we see it as the first website of choice for anyone wanting high quality information about toy shops, toy brands, toy reviews, toy categories or toy organisations.

Ideally we’d like to partner more with independent shops and maybe even work towards some kind of comparison system for just independent shops as most similar systems out there are well outside the budget of most small retailers.

Plans for the future?

Once we have the model perfected, Toy Shop UK is certainly something that could be rolled out to other industry sectors – but I can’t possibly tell you which ones that might be yet!

If you found this post useful, why not buy me a coffee!

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati